10. Data Protection
Corporate marketing departments have always been
hungry for customer data and the Internet has
made it easier than ever before to collect that
data. But there are some rules that must be
respected in the collection and use of data
about customers and visitors to your web site.
Special attention needs to be paid to national
data protection regulations and especially to
the EU Data Protection Directive 95/46/EC of 24
October 1995 and to the Telecommunications Data
Protection Directive 97/66/EC of 15 December
1997. Complying with data protection law is a
complex process that requires a comprehensive
and consistent management approach throughout
the whole organisation.
The Data
Protection Directive aims to ensure the free
flow of data within the Union while safeguarding
the fundamental rights and freedoms of
individuals. It guarantees the confidentiality
of electronic messages and prohibits any kind of
interception or surveillance of such electronic
messages by any party other than the senders and
intended recipients.
According to the directive, Member States must
determine the conditions under which the
processing of personal data is lawful. In any
event the directive provides that personal data
can only be collected for “specified, explicit
and legitimate purposes” and must be processed
in a way which is compatible with these
purposes.
When
collecting data about an individual, there are
several considerations that must be followed.
Collecting
Personal
data can only be collected and processed by the
provider if permitted by some law or if the
individual has unambiguously given his consent.
Use
Data
must not be processed for any purposes
incompatible with those for which the data was
initially collected. Data cannot be transferred
to third parties without agreement from the data
subject. Security measures must be taken to
protect the personal data against any accidental
or unlawful destruction or accidental loss. Data
should not be kept longer than necessary for the
purpose for which it was collected.
Access
Data
should be accurate, complete and kept
up-to-date. The customer must have access to any
personal data concerning him/her that is being
processed or kept. A request for correction or
deletion of incorrect personal data must be
granted within a reasonable period of time. The
customer must have the possibility to opt-out of
the processing operation of his/her data and to
refuse certain use of the data.
The
level of security must be appropriate to the
risk presented by processing and the nature of
the data. The individual has the right to object
to the processing of personal data relating to
him if it is used for the purpose of direct
marketing. Also concerning payment systems are
the compliance with data protection principles
(specified and lawful purposes, adequate,
relevant and not excessive, accurate, securely
held, not transferred to third countries without
adequate protection, consent).
It
should be noted that detecting interception or
surveillance is very difficult. However, there
are numerous security systems on the market to
prevent against surveillance.
Safe Harbour
The Data
Protection Directive prevents transfers of
consumers’ personal data to third countries
where the level of data protection is considered
“inadequate”. The Data Protection Directive
addresses every individual’s right to privacy
with respect to the processing of personal data,
whether processed, stored or used in any
fashion. Information can only be used for the
purposes for which it is obtained, be kept as
long as necessary, and must be kept up-to-date.
Because
US data protection is non-statutory and there is
no government data protection office, it is
regarded as inadequate by definition. Yet
blocking the transfer of business data to the US
is widely regarded to be all but unthinkable,.
Therefore, the European Commission
adopted on 26 July 2000, a
decision on the adequacy of the level of data
protection in the US with the EU Data Protection
Directive. The decision entered into force on 1
November 2000. Any transfer made before this
date is not subject to the decision.
The Commission decision
specifies the conditions under which there is an
adequate level of protection in the US for the
transfer of data from the European Community to
the United States. By agreeing to the safe
harbour principles, US business will therefore
be able to collect data and transfer personal
data between the US and EU Member States. This
way US organisations can keep in line with the
European data protection principles, create
trust and confidence and develop best business
practice.
To guarantee a smooth flow of
data from Europe to the US it is important to
follow this issue. The Safe Harbour is intended
only for the US. There are (as with Hungary and
Switzerland), or will be, other agreements for
other countries.
Commercial Communications
Analysing how off-line and on-line promotion
influence entertainment consumption, a research
company found that web sites and e-mails are as
effective as off-line promotion via magazine
ads, billboards, and theatre previews. Tips
gathered in chat rooms and instant messages are
the most effective means of on-line promotion.
Comparing individual off line promotional tools
with on-line ones revealed that Web promotion
can surpass the power of television.
Commercial communications are essential for the
financing of electronic business and for
developing a wide variety of new, charge-free
services. In the interest of consumer protection
and fair-trading, commercial communication,
including discounts, promotional offers, and
promotional competitions or games, must meet a
number of transparency requirements.
Both the
commercial nature of the communication and the
person for whom the communication is provided
should be clearly identified. In the case of
commercial communications via e-mail, the
commercial nature of the message should be
obvious as soon as the consumer or professional
receives the message. Moreover, the advertiser
must honour opt-out lists – that are public
lists of people who have explicitly asked not to
receive unsolicited commercial e-mail.
The
Electronic Commerce Directive enables Member
States to both authorise and prohibit the
sending of unsolicited commercial communications
by electronic mail.
Where
Member States allow it, it must be “clear and
unambiguously” identifiable as such as soon as
it is received. Besides, Member States can
choose between:
·
an opt-in system (prior consent of the recipient
required before the sending of unsolicited
commercial communications,
Denmark, Italy, Finland, Germany and Austria
have chosen an opt-in system);
or
·
an opt-out system (no sending of unsolicited
advertising to individuals who have mentioned in
a register that they do not wish to receive it).
These opt-out registers would have to be checked
regularly by providers of unsolicited commercial
communications.
Besides
the E-Commerce
Directive, the Distance Selling Directive, the
General and Telecommunications Data Protection
Directive provide different regulation on
commercial communications which creates
confusion.
On July 12, 2000 the European
Commission adopted a proposal for a Directive on
‘processing of personal data and protection of
privacy in the electronic communication sector’.
The proposal is part of a package of proposals
for initiatives which will provide a future
regulatory framework for electronic
communications networks and services. It aims to
adapt and update the existing Data Protection
Telecommunications Directive (97/66/EC) to catch
up with technological developments. Of course
commercial communications send by e-mail are the
most controversially discussed issue. It is not
clear yet, if an opt-in or an opt-out system for
e-mails will apply. If an opt-in system is
chosen the provision of the E-Commerce directive
on this issue would be overruled. The proposal
is still under discussion in Parliament but
expected to be adopted by end of 2001.
Suggestion
Be
careful with unsolicited commercial e-mail,
often known as SPAM. Although the E-commerce
Directive has taken a lenient view on SPAM,
most Internet service providers (ISPs) do not.
Indeed, most ISPs have an acceptable use
policy (AUP) which expressly forbids SPAM and
which you must agree to when subscribing to
the ISPs services.
At the
least, most ISPs will close your account with
little or no warning if you break the AUP.
Some will also charge you costs (the bulk of
the costs of transmitting SPAM are carried by
the ISPs who have to pass it on to their
customers if they cannot collect it from the
persons responsible for the SPAM). Having your
e-commerce site, or even just your e-mail,
suddenly taken down can obviously cause
serious problems to your business.
Moreover, most Internet users do not like
SPAM. The result being that SPAM can actually
have a negative effect, costing you customers
rather than bringing you new customers.
Nevertheless, e-mail marketing can be
effective. However, you should use opt-in
lists – that is lists of people who have
indicated an interest in receiving targeted
e-mail offers. There are a number of highly
reputable companies offering not only opt-in
lists tailored to your target customers, but a
variety of services that allow you to monitor
results, do test runs and change tactics
mid-mailing. To ensure you are dealing with a
reputable e-mail marketing company, ask for
names of clients and check with those clients.
|